The Emperor
Emperor
|
Detail from original woodcut
|
he emperor is one of the more puzzling pictures.
Many commentators think the emperor is about to pass judgment on the kneeling poor man, and that
Death, who's always on the poor people's side, intervenes and breaks the symbol of his power — the sword.
Many commentators have remarked that the emperor looks angrily at the richly dressed, standing man, and takes this
as a sign that the emperor will judge in favour of the poor man.
There are lots of problems with this interpretation.
The first problem is that it is self-contradictory: Why would Death interrupt the process and break the emperor's
sword, if the emperor was going to judge the way Death wanted it?
The second problem is that there's no sword-tip to be found anywhere on the floor.
From Tower of London:
The Sword of Mercy lies between 2 other swords
|
The third problem is that the kneeling man isn't particularly poorly dressed.
There are far poorer people to be found elsewhere in this dance of death, e.g.
the peasant and
the beggar
and the people who implore
the duke,
the advocate and
the senator.
The fourth problem is that it's hard to determine whether the emperor is
looking at the standing man or at his broken sword.
The fifth problem is that the emperor doesn't look particularly angry in Holbein's original woodcut (picture to the left).
And the sixth problem is that one can't use the direction of the emperor's gaze
to read his mood, since Death
is busy twisting his head.
But the biggest problem, which seems to have escaped most of the commentators, is that
a shortened sword — a so-called Curtana/Cortana —
is a symbol of mercy. The broken sword is used for coronation of English kings (see picture to the right),
and the king/emperor uses the sword to raise his subjects to knighthood.
A much more obvious interpretation then, is that the emperor is about to knight the kneeling man.
The picture thus becomes a counterpart of the picture of
the pope,
who's about to crown the emperor. Why is Death turning the emperor's head? Well, that's what he does.
A part of the humour is the total disrespect Death displays towards the high and worthy people:
Death jovially puts his arm around the pope's shoulders, turns
the emperor's head around, twists
the cardinal's
hat, steals
the abbot's
ensigns of power and drags him away, stares into
the nobleman's
eyes while tearing at his clothes, fiddles with
the duke's clothes etc. etc.
Variations: Birckmann adds more persons on both sides of the emperor;
the emperor looks away from his sword; the pillars are human figures. These changes are copied by Valvasor,
but ignored by Hollar/Deuchar.
Various Artists
Dances of death
Holbein's dance of death
Emperor
